The recent addition of Grant Union High School and two other Sacramento landmarks to the National Register of Historic Places has sparked a fascinating discussion about the value and impact of preserving our historical sites. This decision, unanimously supported by the California State Historical Resources Commission, has ignited a conversation that extends beyond the mere recognition of these places.
The Significance of Grant High
For Kelvin Lee, a 1964 Grant graduate and president of the alumni association, the recognition is deeply personal. He sees Grant High as the "axle" of the community, a sentiment that resonates with many alumni and community members. The school's inclusion in the historic register ensures its legacy will be forever etched in the city's history.
A Battle of Perspectives
However, this celebration was not without its challenges. Twin Rivers Unified School District, which Grant High is a part of, initially objected to the listing, citing potential practical implications and the district's need to maintain and improve the campus. Ryan DiGiulio, the district's chief business official, voiced these concerns in a letter to the state. Despite this initial objection, no one from Twin Rivers spoke at the commission meeting, and Commissioner Neal Payton dismissed the concerns, stating that the district should "think creatively" and work collaboratively.
A Community's Pride
Ari Green, another Grant alumna, emphasized the school's significance to her family and the community's pride in the institution. This pride was evident in the absence of objections from Twin Rivers during the meeting, suggesting a resolution to the initial disagreement.
Adaptive Reuse and Community History
The addition of El Dorado Elementary School and the Thomson-Diggs Co. building to the register highlights the importance of adaptive reuse. Sean de Courcy, Sacramento's preservation director, praised the Thomson-Diggs conversion into housing, noting its contribution to addressing the city's housing needs while preserving its industrial history. He also emphasized the importance of recognizing former school buildings like El Dorado, ensuring their history remains integral to the community.
A Broader Perspective
The inclusion of these Sacramento sites on the historic register is part of a larger trend. Across the state, 10 properties were added, including notable buildings in San Francisco, Los Angeles, and San Diego. The presence of the Prince Hall Freemasons at the Vallejo meeting to support Firma Lodge No. 27's nomination further underscores the community's role in preserving historical sites.
Final Thoughts
As we reflect on these additions, it's clear that the National Register of Historic Places serves as a powerful tool for communities to celebrate and preserve their unique histories. While practical considerations are important, the impact of these sites on community identity and the potential for adaptive reuse offer a compelling argument for their preservation. Personally, I think it's a reminder that our historical places are more than just buildings; they are the heart and soul of our communities, and their preservation is a testament to our shared heritage.
